Most of the 10,000 comments this blog has received since December 2005 are respectable and informative. This post is about one comment that was neither. Comments like this represent less than 1% of the total comments received.
On a few fitness posts, I have started closing comments. I usually wait a few years, which is more than enough time to for everyone to provide feedback. Comments that pop up two or more years after the post was published are rarely insightful. They are often written by some blowhard, usually with a fake name, on how he is great and how I am wrong. Rarely does the final commenter bring new facts to the table.
Here is the FINAL comment on my How Tim Ferriss REALLY Gained 34 pounds of Muscle in 28 Days post. A post that was published on January 20, 2011.
My critic uses a fake name, calling himself Big Guy. If you are going to use a fake name, at least use one that we can at least take seriously. Do you think anyone at the gym is saying “I learned something useful from Big Guy today.”?
Now let me pick apart his comment.
BG: You obviously have never used the program.
Whether I used the program or not was not relevant to the post. The post detailed how Tim Ferriss used weight manipulation to “gain 34 pounds of muscle”. If Big Guy had read the post, he would have read this sentence in the second paragraph.
MAS: I also agree that his training and eating protocol are solid programs for mass gaining.
I didn’t just add the bold. It has been there for almost 4 years. Then in a follow up comment, I said this about Tim’s HIT training.
MAS: I’m a huge fan of slow lifting HIT. It is the most effective lifting strategy I’ve ever used.
So I defended Tim’s training protocol twice. Big Guy must have missed that. He continues.
BG: And don’t know what the hell you are talking about.
Point out to me one thing I got wrong in that post. Pull out the The 4-Hour Body (4HB) and then pull out The 4-Hour Workweek (4HWW). Read Tim’s own account of his weight. Line up the dates for yourself. Then read the chapter in the 4HWW where he details how he was able to manipulate his weight while competing in Japan. If you just read the 4HB, you are getting the filtered version. I was fortunate to have read and recalled that info in 4HWW prior to reading the 4HB.
Big Guy continues:
BG: Not only have gained 30 pounds of lean muscle using this program I have also helped several others gain between 10 and 30 pounds of NEW lean muscle in thirty days.
The difference between 10 and 30 is staggering. Here is what I said about 10 pounds.
MAS: Ten pounds is commendable and it is more realistic for an untrained lifter that is working out hard and eating like crazy.
Thirty pounds of new muscle in a month is not realistic. It might be possible, but it is no where near realistic. Give me a malnourished teenager from Samoa and I might have a chance to get 30 pounds on him in a month. But for 99.99% of lifters it isn’t going to happen.
Finally if you were able to help several others gain so much muscle in a month, how do you find time to comment on posts from 2011? I would think you’d have clients lined up around the block throwing money at you. In fact, your name would be known in the fitness community. You wouldn’t need to use fake names on blog comments. And your client base would proof that you were correct. You wouldn’t need to waste your time trying to correct me.
Geek to Freak is still a hoax. Do you know how I know? The book has been out since December 2010. It was a bestseller. Between the book and the supporting blog post, I wouldn’t be surprised if it had an audience of 1 million. Most of them, young healthy males seeking to gain more muscle. Yet almost nobody is still talking about this chapter. It came and went. If it were realistic, there will would A LOT MORE success stories and we would still be talking about it.
The Fremont Troll
My patience for disrespectful fitness comments is wearing thin. I don’t get paid for this. The fitness posts I do are mostly how I would speak to a younger version of myself, with the basic message of don’t believe nonsense and don’t get hurt. If you want to believe fitness fairy tales of muscle gain, knock yourself out.